Animal Law

Wednesday, November 19, 2014

In Pets We Trust?

Do you consider your pet(s) as more than personal property?  I believe most pet owners would agree, but then again most pet owners do not consider his or her pet when making estate plans.  Learn how a Pet Trust might be your best option to plan for your pets health and well-being as part of an estate plan.

Read more . . .

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

Why all veterinarians, rescues, groomers, and kennel owners should know about Poco and PJ

In the summer of 2012 I was fortunate enough to be a summer law clerk for Justice Wil Schroder on the Kentucky Supreme Court.  While there I remember having a discussion about two horses named Poco and PJ that were the subject of a 2001 opinion written by then Judge Schroder on the Court of Appeals.  Now that my wife and I own Riverview Animal Hospital and I represent several veterinarians, boarders, and animal clinics I am certain that anyone dealing with pets on a regular basis should know the story of Poco and PJ and how Kentucky courts value animals as more than property.

Poco (14y) and PJ (13y) were dearly loved horses and treated like "children" by their owner (sound familiar?).  However, the owner became ill with a variety of medical problems that made it difficult for her to care for the horses by herself.  The owner did not want to sell Poco and PJ and instead approached Taylor, a farm owner, willing to do a "free-lease" agreement and keep the horses.  Taylor also agreed the owner could visit when she wanted and would return the horses to the owner if she decided to no longer keep them.  

Within a few days of receiving the horses Taylor sold them for $1,000 to a known slaughter-buyer.  Within a week the owner requested to visit her horses and Taylor lied stating she had given them to an unknown man she met on a trail ride and later convinced a friend to join the ruse.  After sending the owner on a wild goose chase via directions to a fake farm in Indiana the owner discovered through a local humane organization the horses had been sold for slaughter.  Owner sued Taylor requesting, among other things, compensatory and punitive damages based upon emotional damages for the loss of her beloved pets.  Defendants argued that Kentucky only permits recovery of the property value of the horses.

The Kentucky court of appeals upheld an award of $126,000 stating the tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress depends on the facts of the case as to the offender's conduct and not to the subject of said conduct (i.e. horses).  Intentional infliction of emotional distress is available so long as (1) the wrongdoer's conduct is intentional or reckless; (2) the conduct is outrageous against the accepted standards of decency and morality; (3) there is a connection between the conduct and the emotional distress; and (4) the emotional distress is severe.

As courts progress it is my opinion that the standards of intentional infliction of emotional distress will find its way into veterinary malpractice cases and other pet liability actions.  Additionally, Kentucky and other state courts have begun treating animals as humans and setting up trust funds for negligence awards or otherwise finding value beyond market value--like an heirloom.  In either event, courts are increasingly coming to terms that we value pets beyond a remedial market value.

If you or your business have questions regarding intentional infliction of emotional distress please contact us.

Attorney Anthony Mahan is co-owner of Riverview Animal Hospital and member of the American Veterinary Medical Law Association.

Our office is conveniently located in Newport, Kentucky (less than two miles from downtown Cincinnati), but we handle cases throughout the states of Ohio and Kentucky. We also routinely meet with our clients at their offices or homes if more convenient.

© 2019 Law Office of Anthony A. Mahan, PLLC | Disclaimer
102 Fairfield Ave., 2nd Floor, Bellevue, KY 41073
| Phone: (859) 757-1240

Small Business Law | Civil Litigation | Retainer Plans | Entrepreneurs | Veterinary Law | Wills, Trusts, & Estates | Securities Law | Mergers and Acquisitions | Other Areas | | Firm Overview | Reviews | Contact Us | Blog

FacebookGoogle+TwitterLinked-In Personal

Legal Web Development
Zola Creative